The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim

9.5Skill Tree

The skill tree allows the player to choose his path as it should be. The difrence is that in TES 5 it also allows the player to upgrade his ability to do other things such as blacksmithing.

9.0Create Items

You are able to make a lot of stuff which are sometimes very useful.
The only problem is that no matter how much times youll make the same item, you will always get the exact same resault.

10.0Upgrade/Customize Items

You are able to enchant in a really cool way and they made the enchantment feel good.

10.0Difficulty

From easy to Legendary this game offers a lot of options of difficulty.
Can't tell that Legendary is passable since I couldn't finish a game on Legendary.

10.0Loot

Except of the fact that people will stop and wait while you loot, they made the looting system perfect IMO

10.0Open World

Best open world I have seen so far.
So much dungeons to clear and monsters to kill...

9.5Physics Based

The phisics are great tho a giant is not supposed to knock you up in the air for 638338466 meters..

9.0Puzzles

A lot of puzzles in dungeons, at some point they start to be expected.

10.0Quests

Awesome quests for awesome game.

9.5Twitch / Real Time

9.03D

10.0Moddable

From steam workshop to Skyrim nexus, this game have a huge variety of mods and fixes.

PC Controller Support

I've played with a controller for a few hours and I have to admit that it was great- although I'm used to keyboard and mouse.

Steam Trading Cards

I dont really like the emoticons but the backgrounds look really good, the badges look nice and the cards are cool.

Behind/Over The Shoulder

First Person Perspective

I use the first person option and I really like it.

Achievements

Catchy

You'll find yourself singing those soundtracks.

9.0Sound Effects

—Abstract

—Fantasy

10.0Lore